Home Blog Page 682

Panama Papers leak: IT dept has noticed undisclosed credits worth Rs 20,353 cr for 930 India-linked entities

panama papers leak, panama, pandora papers, it department, income tax department, it dept, aishwarya rai, aishwarya rai bachchan, amitabh, corruption, modi, narendra modi, income tax, panama papers india
Panama Papers leak: IT dept has noticed undisclosed credits worth Rs 20,353 cr for 930 India-linked entities 9

The Panama Papers pertain to leaked documents that point towards fraud and tax evasion by many individuals and corporate entities across the world. Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s name featured in the list of 500 Indians who were named in the massive leak of 11.5 million tax documents exposing their secret offshore dealings. Superstar Amitabh Bachchan’s name is also featured in the list.

Vivek Velankar

Vivek Velankar, an RTI activist told Afternoon Voice, “The present government came to power with an assurance that they will bring back the black money and put an end to the corruption, but now after being in power for so many years there is not even a single action or word from the ruling government on this issue. Secondly, in 2019, the topic of corruption or black money has disappeared from their manifesto as well, so there are possibilities of big people being involved in this or the government does not want to do any action on them.”

Deepak Bagri

Deepak Bagri, a Congress worker said, “Black Money reality is slowly dawning on us. It was an empty promise given to gullible voters. We have been taken for a royal ride waiting for the Black money to return to India from foreign. Does this mean we have to forget about Rs 15 lakhs in our account as promised by then the Prime Minister aspirant Modi, who had informed us earlier that Rs.1,35,000 crores of Indian Black Money are residing in Swiss and other banks, which he will target and recover during the Election Campaign?”

Sandeep Manudhane

Sandeep Manudhane an Educationist and Entrepreneur write, “Many of the super-rich Indians, first-generation or otherwise, decided they’ll have nothing or little to do with the regular taxation system back home, as that would be too tiresome, unfair and extortionist. They decided to siphon their wealth, or a large part of it, outside India to places like BVI, Cayman Islands, or Panama, where it’d be safe from the prying eyes of the taxmen, to be enjoyed at leisure later. Sadly, some pure soul in Panama decided to take some load off itself and brought a few lac documents to public attention worldwide! So, we have yet another proof of what everyone suspected always.”

Rajiv Bajaj

Senior journalist Rajiv Bajaj said, “The Panama Papers leak dates to 2016; that’s almost 5-6 years ago. While it is incumbent on all government agencies to investigate even the hint of illegality anywhere, one must remember there is any number of legal and clean entities that also feature in the same leaks. It would be unfair to paint everyone who features in the Panama Papers Leak (as in anyone who has an offshore account or has a foreign registered company) as guilty of money laundering or tax evasion. Unfortunately, since a large number of celebrities are featured in the Panama Papers there will be the inevitable screaming headlines and media trial which I fear will just obfuscate the truth. Just look at what’s happened in the Bofors case, the HDW submarine case, the Jain Hawala Diaries…”

Uttam Agrawal

Uttam Agarwal, Chartered Accountant said, “Governments across the world have begun investigating possible financial wrongdoing by the rich and powerful after a recent leak of four decades of documents from a Panamanian law firm that specialized in setting up offshore companies. The “Panama Papers” revealed the financial arrangements of politicians and public figures. The Papers are an unprecedented leak of 11.5m files from the database of the world’s fourth-biggest offshore law firm, Mossack Fonseca. The records were shared by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ).”

Rajan Shedbalkar

Rajan Shedbalkar, CEO of RJ Academics said, “It is part of the Echo System Developed in Congress timeline. Especially, many foreign companies will be involved in this by taking loopholes in the system. Whether it’s Pandora papers or Panama papers or any other corrupt dealings. People should be investigated whether it’s Amitabh, Sachin or any other big politicians, corporates. Agencies should also declare what they found after investigation. Not only investigation done, but SEBI or relevant agencies should make strong law amendments.”

Navin Bhaven

Navin Bhaven a banker, “There is no verdict about Panama leaks. It makes me raise a few questions. Why the focus is only on Aishwarya Rai? The other names Vinod Adani and KP Singh didn’t come under light and the other 500+ people names in unsolved is still a mystery. Other questions are, whether Aishwarya is the easy target? Or is Aishwarya’s name is protecting shield to safeguard other important names?”

Mohammad Saifi, a tourist driver said, “These types of news are hoaxes. All these while we were listening about Swiss bank accounts, BJP came to power making noises on Swiss accounts and black money, can you see any fruitful conclusion to their claims, similarly it’s UP-election time, they are rabble-rousing about Panama, after elections everything would settle down.”

On the work front, Aishwarya will be next seen in Mani Ratnam’s much-awaited historical film ‘Ponniyin Selvan’, which is based on writer Kalki’s classic novel of the same name. The Enforcement Directorate has summoned actress Aishwarya Rai Bachchan in the Panama Papers Leak case. ED had registered the case after Panama Papers showed how companies were set up in offshore islands to avoid taxes. She is asked to appear before ED’s Delhi office on Monday (December 20).

Aishwarya had sought adjournments on two occasions earlier. The plea of adjournment was made to the special investigation team probing the Panama Papers case. The actress may appear before the prove agency today. The ED wants to question her over allegations of stashing wealth abroad.

On a related note, the Income Tax Department has detected total undisclosed credits worth Rs 20,353 crore for 930 India-linked entities in the Panama and Paradise paper leaks, the government informed the Parliament. Taxes collected so far amount to Rs 153.88 crore in the Panama and Paradise paper leaks, Minister of State for Finance Pankaj Chaudhary stated in a written reply to a question in Rajya Sabha on December 7, 2021.


Salman confirms sequel of ‘Bajrangi Bhaijaan’ in the works

bajrangi bhaijaan, ss rajamouli, salman khan, salman, bhaijaan, bajrangi
Salman confirms sequel of 'Bajrangi Bhaijaan' in the works 11

Superstar Salman Khan has confirmed that he will be featuring in the sequel of his acclaimed blockbuster “Bajrangi Bhaijaan”.

In the 2015 comedy-drama, Khan featured as a man, who embarks on a journey to take a mute six-year-old Pakistani girl (Harshaali Malhotra) separated in India from her parents, back to her hometown in the neighbouring country. The film was directed by Kabir Khan and penned by noted screenwriter KV Vijayendra Prasad. Khan announced the sequel at a special event of filmmaker SS Rajamouli’s upcoming movie “RRR” on Sunday evening.

At the event, which was hosted by filmmaker Karan Johar, the superstar said he has a strong bond with Rajamouli, as his father had penned the much-loved blockbuster. “I have a strong relationship with Rajamouli and his father, as he wrote ‘Bajrangi Bhaijaan’ and soon we will be working together again for ‘Bajrangi Bhaijaan 2’,” Khan said.

When Johar asked if he was confirming that a sequel of “Bajrangi Bhaijaan” was underway, the 55-year-old actor said, “Yes, but now the focus should be on ‘RRR’.” Khan was joined by Rajamouli and the film’s cast, led by Jr NTR and Ram Charan. Alia Bhatt, who features in a special role in the Telugu period actioner, was also present.

“RRR” narrates a fictional tale about two freedom fighters in the early 20th century – Alluri Sitarama Raju, played by Charan and Komaram Bheem, played by Jr NTR. The film is scheduled for a January 7 release.


Dwarfs should be given political reservation

dwarf, drawfism, shivpal, shivpal hyderabad, gattipally shivpal
Dwarfs should be given political reservation 13

People with dwarfism are dealing with a lot of stereotypes in their daily life, and they are constantly fighting against discernment. However, there are a lot of support groups and institutions in a mission to improve the quality of life for Little People, and remove all social barriers, myths and false-negative stereotypes about them. What they need the most is social acceptance.

These little people are like anyone else, big or tall, short or fat – the average lifespan of anyone is going to come down to that individual person’s health. Dwarfism is not so much of a condition of the body but rather a categorical way of defining the person in question. True there can be physical limitations placed on an individual with dwarfism, again depending on the person and what kind of dwarfism they have. They are like you and me; they have every right to live a normal life. These days many Dwarf members have won medals for the country and most of them are equally contributing to the Indian economy.

The things little people have to deal with are often unique to their situation. For some, the hardest part of being a little person is the acumen they face. Living as a little person is like being the main attraction at the circus. Going grocery shopping, going to public places – it’s like being a celebrity, and the whole world is their paparazzi. Some laugh at them and some get amused and most of the people click pictures with them to showcase.

This constant attention is killing, and even frightening. The attention involves pointing, staring, derogatory comments, and outright bullying. Their existence is a joke to people. We need to understand they too need privacy and space, they need their corner and they need normal acceptance. The deliberate attention is very bad and uncomfortable. We need to educate our children to behave normally with them.

They face various challenges at ATMs, ticket machines, gas pumps, and self-service checkout registers can be difficult, if not impossible, for little people to use. All of these machines are designed with the average adult height in mind, which makes reaching the device in order to operate it a challenge. While adaptive devices do exist, they aren’t always convenient. Car Airbags are designed to protect against serious injury in a car crash, but they can be fatal for little people. That’s because they’re designed to meet average-sized people in the chest and abdomen, which means that they can smother people of shorter stature.

Shoes are usually designed either for children or for average-sized adults. Little people’s feet are often the length of children’s feet, but they can be much too wide to fit into children’s sizes. Even if children’s sizes do fit, finding styles that are appropriate for adults can be challenging. Dating isn’t easy under the best of circumstances, but for little people, there are some extra obstacles. Little people have two choices: they can either date other little people, or they can date average-sized people. Both present their own sets of issues. Dating average-sized people often means facing prejudice, if not from the person they’re dating, then from their family and friends. It’s not uncommon for little people to hear things like “if you weren’t little, I would date you.”

While dating inside the community means shared experiences and understanding, it isn’t always easy either. As of now, only Telangana and Kerala have done something to help this community. The Uttarakhand government, in January, offered an allowance of ₹800 per month to eligible dwarf adults and also gave them reservations in certain services of the state government but implementation is still an issue. No other states have even given a thought to making these lives better. They don’t even have government job quotas.

There are no dedicated groups or active organizations to ensure the rights of dwarfs in India. In India, sympathy is seen mostly for people with disabilities. However, the problem is also that there are very few organized groups that are fighting for the rights of the dwarf population. They should get together and demand their rights collectively. It is also important to give them political reservations. If they aren’t politically represented, it will be tough for them to fight for their rights. We all need to raise our voices for fellow humans.


Any suggestions, comments or disputes with regards to this article send us at feedback@www.afternoonvoice.com

Dwarf Lives Matter – Shiv Lal from Hyderabad fighting for justice

shiv lal, dwarf, dwarfism, hyderabad, phd
Dwarf Lives Matter - Shiv Lal from Hyderabad fighting for justice 15

“Dwarfism” is identified as a form of disability, but still, nothing much is done for these little humans. Shiv Lal, a dwarf told Afternoon Voice, “I am the only licensed car driver. We get many challenges while getting a driving license, jobs, and people think we are circus jokers. They do not take us seriously.”

Shiv Lal who received an Honorary PhD said, “I am married and my son is a normal person but to raise him my wife and I had to deal with various challenges.”

He said people used to tease us, more than the tease and taunts, what pains us more is the society’s blissful ignorance towards our community’s need to live like normal human beings. The focus of attention is almost always on the visible distortion that other individual aspects of a dwarf such as his/her desire to get married, have sex or start a family, often gets ignored or even ridiculed.

Shiv Lal further said, “I have fought all odds and lived a normal life, unlike a majority of my community members who live a hidden life due to societal stigma and shame, and often in unending poverty. Now my mission is to fight for the rights of Dwarfs, because these lives matter.”

Social worker Zenobia Khodaiji said, “Dwarfs face problems that most other people don’t give a second thought to. Public urinals aren’t fixed while keeping people of such short stature in mind. Chairs and desks aren’t dwarf-friendly. Public transport doesn’t have ramps for easy entry and exit for them and even cars don’t come equipped with specifications to suit their needs. It’s high time the government needs to do something for them.”

Their problems are very similar to wheelchair-dependent people says Shabnam Rangwala, head of therapy at ADAPT, India’s first special school for children with cerebral palsy. “In India, infrastructure is not friendly to people like them.”

“People with dwarfism are able to perform all normal activities but need help to do them because of their height and certain other physical characteristics peculiar to them,” said Dr Anshuman Manaswi.

Prince Mohammed bin Salman – New Hope for Saudi Arabia

Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Prince Salman, Crown Prince, Saudi Arabia, Saudi, Bin Salman, Salman
Prince Mohammed bin Salman - New Hope for Saudi Arabia 17

He is both a hope and a scare. His societal reforms are long-awaited and will surely be important and positive in the long run, shy as they may look to western eyes. His aggression against Yemen and Qatar etc. are very terrifying. The Yemen war is a new Vietnam in terms of humanitarian crisis and there is no solution in sight, but still.

He has introduced a series of urgently needed social and economic reforms as part of the Kingdom’s Vision 2030. Women were given their full legal rights (the male-guardianship system was abolished, lifted the ban on women’s driving, women’s participation in the workforce was boosted, Hijab has become a personal choice). Opened up the country for foreign investment and tourism (for the first time! Saudi Arabia plans to host more than 100 million visitors per year by the year 2030).

Lifted the ban on music festivals and international events (it hosted WWE, Formula E, MDLBEAST music festival, along with other exciting regional and international events). Non-oil revenues increased to 48% of the annual budget’s revenue. Increased the assets of the Saudi Public Investment Fund (PIF) from 500 million Riyals to 1.5 trillion Riyals. (The fund is expected to bring in 150 million Riyals to the Saudi economy every year). Introduced initiatives to reduce Saudi Arabia’s carbon emission through launching the Saudi Green Initiative and the Middle East Green Initiative. Invested heavily in renewable energy (solar, wind and hydrogen fuel). Saudi Arabia is expected to export clean energy to the rest of the world.

Saudi woman believes that Mohammed bin Salman is the best thing that happened to Saudi Arabia in a very long time. Societies with greater gender equality not only offer better socioeconomic opportunities for women but also tend to grow faster and more equitably. There are gains in poverty reduction, environmental sustainability, consumer choice, innovation and decision-making on a wider set of issues. Lowering the barriers faced by women entrepreneurs at home and internationally, and helping more businesswomen to connect to international value chains, would bolster growth and inclusion. It would create more – and better-paying – jobs for women, not least since women-owned firms hire more women, especially at senior levels. The overall growth of women in the development of the country.

That is why taking gender into account matters when developing and implementing trade policy. Placing women at the heart of global policymaking will go a long way towards realizing the United Nations 2030 Agenda goal of achieving gender equality and empowering all women and girls. Economic development and gender equality go hand-in-hand. He appointed women in senior roles in the government and the private sector as part of a massive campaign to empower women.

He also cracked down on corruption ($100 billion was retrieved). Invested in renewable energy (Saudi Arabia enjoys one of the best locations in the world for sun exposure which can be used to export solar energy to the rest of the world, remaining yet again, an energy provider). Launched mega-projects that are 100% powered by renewable energy such as NEOM, the Red Sea Islands, Amala.

Young future King, Mohammed bin Salman was born on 31 August 1985, the eldest son of Prince Salman bin Abdul Aziz Al Saud’s third wife, Fahda bint Falah Al Hithlain. After gaining a bachelor’s degree in law at King Saud University in the capital Riyadh, he worked for several state bodies. In 2009, he was appointed a special adviser to his father, who was serving as governor of Riyadh at the time.

Mohammed bin Salman’s rise to power began in 2013 when he was named the head of the Crown Prince’s Court, with the rank of minister. The previous year, his father had been appointed crown prince after the death of Nayef bin Abdul Aziz. In January 2015, King Abdullah bin Abdul Aziz died and Salman acceded to the throne at the age of 79.

The new king immediately made two decisions that surprised observers, naming his son minister of defence and nephew Mohammed bin Nayef deputy crown prince. The latter became the first of the grandsons of Ibn Saud, the founder of the kingdom, to move on to the line of succession. One of Mohammed bin Salman’s first acts as defence minister was to launch a military campaign in Yemen in March 2015 along with other Arab states after the Houthi rebel movement, which they saw as an Iranian proxy, seized control of the capital Sanaa and forced President Abdrabbuh Mansour Hadi to flee abroad.

In April 2015, King Salman made more startling changes to the line of succession, appointing Mohammed bin Nayef as crown prince and his son deputy crown prince, second deputy prime minister and president of the Council of Economic and Development Affairs. The plan, called Vision 2030, envisages increasing non-oil revenue to 600bn riyals ($160bn; £123bn) by 2020 and 1trn riyals by 2030, up from 163.5bn riyals in 2015. The prince said he wanted to create the world’s largest sovereign wealth fund, worth up to $3ten, with money generated by partially privatizing the state oil company, Saudi Aramco.

In April 2017, the kingdom announced plans for a 334 sq km (129 sq mile) entertainment city on the edge of Riyadh offering a range of cultural and sporting activities – including a safari park. The prince was also seen as having spearheaded a boycott of Qatar, which Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Egypt began in early June 2017 over its alleged support for terrorism and meddling in its neighbours’ affairs. However, the Khashoggi case has shifted the focus towards the darker side of Salman’s record, one that includes the imprisonment of critics and human rights activists, thousands of civilian deaths in Yemen and a rapid rise in the number of executions since his ascent to power.


Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman to be Saudi Arabia’s uncrowned king

crown prince, mohammed bin salman, salman, bin salman, prince, mohammed, saudi arabia, arabia, saudi, prince salman, king salman
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman to be Saudi Arabia's uncrowned king 19

Mohammed Bin Salman a relatively unknown individual who was one of one among the many sons of the King Salman of Saudi Arabia was declared heir apparent to the throne in 2015, as a young leader of only 33 years of age, he could very well understand and touch the chord of young Saudis in his country, his notable reforms are appreciated worldwide.

With amplified concerns over the nearly 86-year-old King Salman’s health, Prince Mohammed, 36, is taking charge of presidential meetings and reception of dignitaries, with the king rarely making public appearances. From greeting foreign leaders to heading regional summits, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is taking over the reins from his elderly father and becoming Saudi Arabia’s uncrowned king.

While Prince Mohammed has been considered the de facto leader since his appointment as heir to the throne in June 2017, his growing prominence has never been more apparent than when he met with French President Emmanuel Macron in early December and led the Gulf Cooperation Council summit on Tuesday. King Salman, who usually heads the annual meeting after warm embraces and friendly handshakes, was a no-show.

An Indian Businessman staying in Saudi said under the condition of anonymity “On the one hand Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has made some changes to the treatment of about half of KSA’s citizens, by giving women the right to drive. There are more changes but they have tended to be cosmetic. His extra-judiciary arrest and holding to ransom dozens of Saudi billionaires gained him, or KSA, hundreds of billions. That these billionaires were treated roughly and at least one died is of no concern to MBS. Even if these billionaires had crookedly gained their fortune, there was certainly no attempt of the due process of law, which does not really exist in KSA. The action against these billionaires was corrupt because, I am sure that similar billionaires, who were friends of Mohammed bin Salman, were left untouched.”

Another critic said “Mohammed bin Salman is an arrogant upstart, who has been given governmental powers far greater than his tiny intellect can cope with, like many despots and dictators around the world and in the past. To answer the question, Mohammed bin Salman has made KSA into a worse place in which to live with minor cosmetic changes to appease those critics abroad.”

A local Saudi merchant told Afternoon Voice “The most important is the announcement of Saudi vision 2030, which is an ambitious economic plan involving mammoth investments of 200–300 trillion $ to diversify the economy of Saudi Arabia and reduce its dependence on oil whose prices issues are highly volatile and to make Saudi Arabia a hub of infrastructure and develop it into one of the most developed countries of the world. Mohammed bin Salman can do much better for Saudi Arabia because he has the will and attitude”.

Since the outbreak of Covid-19, King Salman has been residing in Neom, a futuristic development on the Red Sea. His last meeting with a foreign official in Riyadh was in March 2020, when he sat down with the-UK foreign minister Dominic Raab, and his last trip abroad was to Oman to offer his condolences over the death of Sultan Qaboos in January 2020.

Prince Mohammed has sought to position himself as a champion of moderate Islam, even as his international reputation took a hit from the 2018 murder and dismemberment of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi in the kingdom’s Istanbul consulate. The crown prince, also known as MBS, has opened Saudi Arabia to tourists and foreign investments in an effort to diversify the economy of the world’s largest oil exporter economy away from crude.

He has overseen sweeping social changes, including allowing women to drive and work in the public sector, enabling citizens to enjoy the additional income and recreational outlets that opened up across the country. These changes have come alongside a crackdown on dissent and free speech. He even seemed more open than his father towards Israel, allowing its commercial aircraft to pass through Saudi air space.


The US in its report says, “Terror groups targeting India continue to operate from Pakistan”

pakistan, pak, terrorist, us report on terrorism, pakistan terrorist, masood azhar, mumbai attack, 2008 mumbai attack, us
The US in its report says, "Terror groups targeting India continue to operate from Pakistan" 21

Terror groups targeting India continue to operate from Pakistan which did not act against known terrorists, including JeM chief and UN-blacklisted Masood Azhar and 2008 Mumbai attack “project manager” Sajid Mir, who remain free in that country, according to the latest US report on terrorism.

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken, in the 2020 Country Reports on Terrorism issued on Thursday, said that regionally, terrorist groups continued to operate from Pakistan.

“Groups targeting Afghanistan — including the Afghan Taliban and affiliated Haqqani Network (HQN), as well as groups targeting India, including Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) and its affiliated front organisations, and Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) — continued to operate from Pakistani territory,” according to the report.

Pakistan did not take action against other known terrorists such as JeM founder and UN-designated terrorist Azhar and 2008 Mumbai attack “project manager” Mir, both of whom are believed to remain free in Pakistan, the report said.

In February and again in November, a Lahore anti-terrorism court convicted LeT founder Hafiz Saeed on multiple counts of terrorism financing and sentenced him to five years and six months in prison, the report noted.

The US report acknowledged that Pakistan made additional progress in 2020 towards completing its Financial Action Task Force (FATF) Action Plan, but did not complete all Action Plan items, and remained on the FATF “grey list”.

The report also noted that some madrassas in Pakistan continued to teach violent extremist doctrine. ”While the government continued efforts to increase madrassa regulation, some analysts and madrassa reform proponents observed that many madrassas failed to register with the government, provide documentation of their sources of funding, or comply with laws governing acceptance of foreign students,” it said.

Highlighting the US-India cooperation, the report said that the United States continues to build its strategic partnership with the Government of India, including through bilateral engagements such as the 17th Counterterrorism Joint Working Group and Third Designations Dialogue in September, as well as the third 2+2 Ministerial Dialogue in October.

It also commended the Indian counterterrorism forces, including the National Investigation Agency (NIA), for actively detecting and disrupting transnational and regional terror forces.

“Indian counterterrorism forces, at the federal and state levels, actively detected and disrupted transnational and regional terror forces.

“The National Investigation Agency (NIA) examined 34 terrorism-related cases related to ISIS and arrested 160 persons, including 10 alleged al-Qaeda operatives from Kerala and West Bengal, in September,” the report said.

It further said that in the wake of the 2019 Easter Sunday suicide attacks by ISIS-inspired terrorists, Sri Lanka continued efforts to enhance its counterterrorism capabilities and improve border security, including through engagement with the US and other international partners, though progress on some cooperative initiatives stalled in light of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Sri Lankan police continued to cooperate with the FBI on the ongoing investigation into the 2019 Easter attacks. More than 100 suspects remain in custody.

Sri Lankan indictments remained pending at year’s end. The US Department of Justice announced charges against three individuals for their roles in the killing of five US citizens during the 2019 attacks.

Nine suicide bombers, belonging to local Islamist extremist group National Thawheed Jamaat (NTJ) linked to ISIS, carried out a series of blasts that tore through three churches and as many luxury hotels in Sri Lanka, killing 258 people, including 11 Indians, and injuring over 500 on the Easter Sunday on April 21, 2019.


Bullock Cart race – How can one define cruelty to animals?

bullock cart, bullock cart race, bull race, bull cart, jallikattu
Bullock Cart race - How can one define cruelty to animals? 23

The Supreme Court in an order permitted the resumption of the bullock cart race in Maharashtra after four years on the same conditions and regulations as mentioned in the state amendments to Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act by Karnataka and Tamil Nadu. However, it is requested that all these races be conducted in strict compliance with the terms and conditions laid down by the State Government.

In 2014 Supreme Court had banned Jallikattu, bull-race and bullock-cart races across the country accepting that these violated provisions of the PCA Act. However, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu had amended the PCA Act to allow regulated bull races, which are also under challenge now and pending in SC for over 3 years.

The BJP-led government in 2017 had passed the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Maharashtra Amendment) Bill by amending the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (1960). There were provisions to ensure there is no injury to the participating animals. Organizers violating the rules will face up to three years of imprisonment or have to pay up to Rs 5 lakh as a fine.

The legislation was sent to the Union Home Minister and to the President of India in August 2017 for consent. After the government had received the consent, the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) approached the Bombay High Court challenging the law. The high court upheld the petitioner’s plea and stayed the implementation of the Act. Subsequently, bullock cart race lovers filed a petition challenging the high court order in the apex court. However, SC ruled that all petitions in this regard will be heard by a Constitution Bench.

Bullock-cart race lovers believe that there is a systematic attack on Hindu or native Indian traditions of late. You name the festival, and in the name of feminism, environment or animal rights, the festivals are being attacked. Buffalo fight during Magh Bihu in Assam, buffalo race called Kampala in Karnataka, cock fight in Andhra/Telangana and much more and Baligadi race in Maharashtra are traditional animal sports which were celebrated for ages.

It is almost impossible for a bull in Jallikattu to die. If at all any injuries or death happen, the chances are that they happen to the humans trying to tame the bull. For just 15 to 30 seconds of interaction with humans, a bull is taken care of for the entire year like a celebrity. All these animals in the sport are an asset to the owner, there is nothing wrong when the bull is pampered for the whole year, fed well and treated royally, for a few seconds of running amidst the crowd.

In our country leather goods are not banned, meat-eating is permissible, artificial breeding and all other atrocities are allowed, milling of cats and dogs is business, mulching cows with machines is allowed, several species are going extinct but we don’t care. The people who rear bulls don’t find much remuneration. This is one of the only things a bull helps them besides breeding. Besides, this keeps the bull in its true flora. The bull is meant to be a powerful animal. That is why the bulls toiled in the field. This is not animal abuse. This is the animal’s natural habit over hundreds of years.

If injury and death is a reason to ban a sport, then Cricket and Football would have to be inspected. We know that people have died on Cricket pitches or football grounds many times, making those games more dangerous for lives, compared to Jallikattu! Remember Raman Lamba, Darryn Randall or Philip Huges?

Take any human sports, danger is everywhere be it stunts in films or sports. If they are approved what is the point in banning animal sports? No circus was ever banned where wildlife is at stake. All cultures throughout history have used animals in the context of sport and entertainment, from Roman chariot racing up to present-day hunting, racing, and circuses. What we need is a good rulebook to monitor the conditions of the animals involved. Or if we are really sensitive about animals in general, then stop caging parrots and birds and home, stop petting dogs and cats and treat them like humans and try to discipline them, stop keeping fish in limited pond water, stop eating flesh and meat. Stop killing rats, stop caging animals. Even if you care for your pets, possessing them against the nature of their living is cruel.


Supreme Court sanctions Maharashtra to conduct Bailgadi Sharyat (Bullock Cart race) in accordance with 2017 Rules

supreme court, sc, bullock cart race, bullock, race, animals rights, peta india, peta, animal activists, Bailgadi Sharyat
Supreme Court sanctions Maharashtra to conduct Bailgadi Sharyat (Bullock Cart race) in accordance with 2017 Rules 25

The Supreme Court on Thursday allowed the Maharashtra government to conduct bullock cart races in the state in accordance with the rules and the amendments made by it to the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act.

The order was passed by the top court bench comprising Justices AM Khanwilar and CT Ravikumar while hearing the interim application in Maharashtra’s special leave petition, which was filed in 2018 challenging the stay order passed by the Bombay High Court against the conduct of bullock cart races in the state.

Maharashtra Home Minister Dilip Walse Patil and Minister of Sports and Animal Husbandry Sunil Kedar on Thursday welcomed the Supreme Court’s decision on lifting the ban on bullock cart races in the state.

The application filed by Maharashtra urged the apex court to permit it to conduct a bullock-cart race. One of the advocates appearing in the matter had earlier told the apex court that the bullock-cart race was banned in Maharashtra on the ground that it was cruelty to the animal.

The Maharashtra government has said that there is a prohibition on bullock-cart race in the state as the Bombay High Court in its interim order had refused to lift the ban in 2017, while there is no stay on the concerned Acts of the other two states. Jallikattu, also known as ‘eruthazhuvuthal’, is a bull-taming sport played in Tamil Nadu as part of the Pongal harvest festival.

The Maharashtra government had on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that the ban on bullock-cart race in the state should be lifted as the same is going on in states like Tamil Nadu and Karnataka.

The state government had told a bench of Justices A M Khanwilkar and C T Ravikumar that they should be allowed to conduct bullock-cart races in accordance with the 2017 Rules. Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for Maharashtra, said the Bombay High Court had stayed the operation of the Rules by which the state wanted to hold bullock-cart races under strict regulations.

“The ban should be removed and we should be allowed to conduct races in accordance with the Rules of 2017,” he told the bench, which was hearing an application filed by Maharashtra in the matter. He said the top court can ask for the supervision of the collector concerned, who can be answerable. “The rules itself provide for that,” the bench observed. Rohatgi said the bench can issue a word of caution and the state would take full care.

He referred to the earlier order of the apex court, which had referred the pleas related to ‘Jallikattu’ to a five-judge Constitution bench which would decide if the bull-taming sport fell under cultural rights or perpetuated cruelty to animals.

 “For the last three years, since it was referred to a Constitution bench, all the other adjoining states are enjoying this bullock cart race. Our state is unable to do it, despite that it is in an identical position,” Rohatgi said.

He said the high court’s interim order of the high court should be modified and the state be permitted to conduct the bullock-cart race. The senior advocate said several pleas challenging the law of other states, which are identical to that of Maharashtra, are pending before the apex court and there is no stay on them.


Modi has changed the political discourse of the country

uttar pradesh, uttar pradesh elections, up elections, narendra modi, modi, yogi adityanath, yogi, akhilesh yadav, akhilesh
Image: PTI

You can’t run a country like India with just one discourse narrated by Congress and left-liberals for so long. This discourse was bound to come and will continue for another 30-40 years. Modi successfully abolished caste-based politics and took it to religion-based politics. Those local politicians who sustained on cast votes not getting dentin their vote share. He also gave a run to the regional political parties including Congress for their monies. The opposition parties have no idea to suggest to the nation what programmes they have but have only one agenda to remove Modi.

 Most of the third front regional political outfits in India claim that all that Modi is doing were their original ideas. Those who implement original ideas are remembered but not those who dreamt but never attempted to implement much less actually did so. We cannot say Modi has not done anything; he has done all that pleases his voters and supporters. Yes, India including Uttar Pradesh needed education, medical facilities, jobs and those promised smart cities. But we are Happy with Hindutva and Hindu sentiments. We give damn to policy failures because Modi has passed in making our most precious issue Ram Mandir, and soon we are going to see the demolition of another Masjid in Mathura. We want our Hindu Rashtra and Hindutva fire burning in us.

Recently the PM went to a ceremony in Varanasi – he did the needful, dipping in the Ganges and offering prayers, all that we do as Hindus. What is the need to criticize every point of it? Was it done to consolidate votes? Maybe yes – remember BJP is a political party too. They need to do these to win the elections as well. When Mamata delayed Dussehra for Muharram to take place, was it not appeasement? When Manmohan said a minority has the first right to a country’s resources, was it not appeasement? No one will talk about these but the PM took one dip in the Ganga people felt so disgusting?

Well! Now let us come back to our election topic, In Uttar Pradesh, there are three main parties that play a major role in elections. Those parties are BJP, SP, and BSP but this time for a change it’s Congress too. Other parties like Apna Dal(S), RLD, Aam Aadmi Party, can play the trump card if there is going to be a hung assembly. Caste, Religion, Ayodhya Mandir, Loyal voters of parties, Law & Order situation, Influence of Riots and religious battle and lastly health, education, and employment that plays vital roles. So keeping all these factors in mind we can understand how the current government is the favourite player for the 2022 election. The current status and position of some leading parties in UP and how the AAP and AIMIM can affect the election scenario is another segment to mark the accuracy of predictions.

Modi magic still works, Yogi is a prominent Hindutva icon and Hindutva will be the factor that makes BJP the favourite party for the UP voters. More than this no party as a single player can defeat BJP in the UP. Samajwadi Party is the second-largest party in Uttar Pradesh. The main advantage to SP is cast votes. But the demerit can be family disputes, diminishing influence of SP in their bastion, party’s internal disputes over the leadership, and much more. It can be sure that in single combat the SP can’t defeat the BJP.

Bahujan Samaj Party, strong leadership and caste votes. If the BSP forms an alliance with INC and SP, then it can dent the BJP’s dream to retain the UP in 2022. But alliance either with SP or INC won’t help the BSP to get more than 40+ seats. INC was the party that once dominated UP politics for a decade. But with the rise of BJP, the weak organization of INC, and the popularity of Yogi, INC lost its vote share.

To revive the situation, INC appointed Priyanka. But it didn’t work as Rahul lost his seat in the UP general election 2019. Without the support of SP or BSP, it is for sure that INC can’t win even ten minimum seats. Apna Dal(S) is the alliance partner of BJP in the general election and Assembly election since 2014. With the support from the BJP’s brand and its own caste votes, it is performing and showing better scores in comparison to INC and RLD.

 But if the AD(S) wants to go solo then it won’t win more than two seats in the upcoming assembly election 2022. Rashtriya Lok Dal party is struggling to find its identity. Once they were very much capable of getting 30+ seats on their own. But now the situation has changed after the 2014 general election.

All India Majlis E Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM), if this time they manage to get good vote shares in UP then it will be a high alert situation for SP and INC. It will affect their vote banks and boost BJP to concrete their position. As the UP has a 19% population from the Muslim community, it is creating a successful stage for the AIMIM. If the AIMIM won’t contest in UP, then it will be the INC and SP who will get the benefit and vice versa.

The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) has no influence on UP. It can’t influence the election scenario like the AIMIM. Like Bhagbant Mann in Punjab, there is no candidate or leader in UP, who can lead the party. AAP might get less than 1% votes in the upcoming assembly election 2022 in UP.

In this election, BJP will fight along with Apna Dal(S) against all the parties. But as per the current scenario, it looks like the fight will be NDA Vs SP Vs BSP Vs UPA Vs Others. Under this combination with the help of the following factors, Yogi will easily win the election. His effort to make UP an industrial hub will help him to counter the unemployment issues. The progress of Ram Mandir accelerated his popularity in UP, Modi Magic will be the factor to get additional votes in every assembly seat. The negative approach of INC towards Ram Mandir, Article 370, and Triple Talaq will help BJP to get additional votes in every assembly seat. BJP losing the UP assembly election is unlikely. Maybe BJP may secure a little less than what they got in 2017. BJP will be forming the government ultimately.