Home Blog Page 1010

Unsold Luxury Housing Stock Declines 12% in 1 Year

unsold luxury houses
Image Courtesy: economictimes.com
  • Overall unsold inventory of luxury homes (priced INR 1.5 cr – INR 2.5 cr) declines to 42,650 units in Q1 2019 from 48,300 units in Q1 2018
  • MMR currently accounts for maximum share at 56%
  • Bangalore sees 49%, Kolkata 37% yearly decline in total unsold ultra-luxury homes
  • NCR and MMR each saw a 7% decline in pent-up luxury inventory during the year
  • Mid-segment (INR 40 lakh – INR 80 lakh) saw max. reduction with 14%; affordable (<INR 40 lakh) saw a 3% rise in total unsold stock in this period

The slowdown in Indian residential real estate over the last few years caused most high net-worth individuals (HNIs) to shun luxury housing and look at other investments within or outside real estate. However, ANAROCK’s latest study indicates that HNIs are now using the tail end of the slowdown in India’s luxury residential market to their advantage.

Stagnant prices and best-buy deals have brought back some of the demand luxury homes, leading to a decline of 12% in this segment’s overall unsold stock in one year. To put it in numbers, the current unsold stock of luxury homes (priced between INR 1.5 cr to INR 2.5 cr) has reduced to approx. 42,650 units against approx. 48,300 units as on Q1 2018.

Typically, the investment portfolios of HNIs and UHNIs have about 30-35% of the total investments in real estate. That said, the majority of HNIs and UHNIs who have triggered this reduction trend are end-users who perceive that luxury housing prices have bottomed out. Developers are also offering attractive deals and further discounts to clear their unsold luxury stock.

Among the top 7 cities, MMR predictably accounted for the maximum share of unsold luxury housing stock at about 23,930 units in Q1 2019, while Kolkata had the least stock with around 770 units.

Bangalore led from the front, recording a whopping 49% decline in unsold luxury stock within a year – from 6,370 units in Q1 2018 to 3,260 units in Q1 2019 (ANAROCK’s recent Consumer Sentiment Survey confirms that nearly 31% NRIs currently prefer to invest in Bangalore).

Bangalore’s notable luxury inventory-shedding performance was followed by Kolkata, which offloaded 37% of unsold luxury homes in the same period. On the other hand, Chennai and Hyderabad saw unsold luxury homes pile up further by 50% and 10% respectively.

The two most expensive markets of NCR and MMR each saw a 7% yearly decline, with NCR currently holding ‘just’ 9,590 unsold luxury units as on Q1 2019 and MMR still saddled with 23,930 unsold luxury units.

NCR saw its maximum housing sales in the mid-segment category, with overall unsold stock in this category reducing by 20%. This, in fact, is becoming a nation-wide trend.

Mid-segment Sees Highest Reduction in Unsold Inventory

Overall, unsold stock of mid-segment housing (priced between INR 40 lakh and INR 80 lakh) saw the maximum decline of 14% during this one-year period. As it stands now, unsold stock in this segment across the top 7 cities is nearly 2.25 lakh units, second only to the affordable segment which accounts for 2.42 lakh unsold units.

Contrary to previous trends, the overall unsold stock in the affordable housing category (priced <INR 40 lakhs) saw a 3% increase since Q1 2018. This jump in unsold stock is primarily because this segment saw the maximum new launches in 2018. It accounted for a 40% share of the total of 1,95,300 units launched in the year. That said, with more and more buyers looking to buy affordable properties on account of several incentives such as lower GST rates, this unsold affordable stock is likely to reduce going forward.

– By Anuj Puri

(The author is the Chairman – ANAROCK Property Consultants)

‘Common glue may help fight climate change’

climate crisis
Image Courtesy: Pixabay

Researchers have developed a new material containing common glue molecules which may help tackle climate change by capturing the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (CO2) directly from the air.

Carbon capture materials are a crucial part of a range of technologies, alongside renewables and energy efficiency solutions, that can help reduce the amount of CO2 we release into the atmosphere, according to the research published in the journal Chemistry of Materials.

“We show that small epoxy molecules typically found in glues can stick larger ones together to make effective carbon capture materials potentially useful to tackle climate change,” said Enrico Andreoli, from Swansea University in the UK.

“We’ve developed a new approach to making an effective CO2 capture material from a widely studied CO2-reactive polyamine by reaction with an industrially mass-produced epoxy resin,” Louise Hamdy, first author of the research paper, added.

“This material shows very high CO2 uptake and could potentially be used to capture CO2 from industrial flue gas streams or from the air, relieving us from some of the worst effects of global warming,” Hamdy said.

Current CO2 capture technologies need to be significantly advanced.

Major challenges include materials cost, capacity, CO2-selectivity, regeneration, robustness, and stability to water.

Solid CO2 capture materials composed of polyamines supported on alumina or silica have emerged as promising carbon capture materials.

The researchers cross-linked the polyamine into a solid by using epoxy resin — constituting just one-tenth of the mass of the material –maximising the CO2-reactive component and avoiding the use of a support.

“This confirms the validity of my original idea of using cross-linking as an alternative to bulky supports,” said Andreoli.

The cross-linked material modified with a hydrophobic additive captured almost 20 per cent of its weight in pure CO2 at 90 degrees Celsius, researchers said.

This finding confirmed a previous hypothesis that the introduction hydrophobic groups can disrupt the internal structure of the material to promote CO2 uptake by the polyamine, they said.

The additive not only increased the amount of captured CO2 but did so at a lower temperature.

“This finding is significant as it proves that through the introduction of additives, we can fine tune these materials for optimum performance at specific working temperatures,” Hamdy said.

Experiments revealed the functionalised sample to be highly selective for CO2 over nitrogen (N2), showing negligible uptake of N2.

Selectivity was further explored by testing the material performance under flue gas-like conditions.

This revealed that the sample could capture 9.5 per cent of its weight in CO2 under a dilute CO2 stream of 10 per cent CO2/90 per cent N2 at 90 degrees Celsius in only 15 minutes.

The functionalised material also performed exceptionally well under humid conditions — often a huge challenge for many CO2 sorbent solids.

At 25 degrees, in pure CO2, the pre-hydrated material was able to capture an impressive 23.5 per cent, researchers said.

This opens up the possibility of this material being developed for capture of CO2 directly from the air, they said.

Will govt’s big step to ensure equitable water supply be helpful?

mumbai water
Image Courtesy: rediff.com

Minister of State for Urban Development Yogesh Sagar on Thursday said that a report on equitable water distribution across Mumbai has been prepared and the Maharashtra government will ask the city civic body to implement it.

Responding to a question raised by NCP member Rahul Narvekar through a Calling Attention notice in the state Legislative Council, Sagar said, “A comprehensive report on equitable water distribution for Mumbai city and its suburban areas is ready. The report will be shared with the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) soon and the civic body will be asked to implement it.”

To another question, he said people living on forest land in Mumbai for years were not getting adequate drinking water supply, but the government will soon ensure it for them.

Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis in 2016 announced setting up a committee to ensure equitable water distribution for the region coming under the jurisdiction of the BMC.

The minister also noted that the Mumbai civic body loses around 25 to 27 per cent water due to leakages. “The government is trying hard to minimise such losses so that it can cater to the growing drinking water demand,” he said.

Sagar said that though the number of city’s permanent residents is limited, its floating population (those who keep moving from place to place) puts a lot of pressure on the administration.

“It is necessary to supply 270 litre of water per person in city areas, mainly due to the pressure of the floating population,” the minister said.

Healing touch through Yoga

Yoga, Health is wealth, Yoga healthYoga is approximately 4,000 years old and is a scientific methodology aimed at uniting the mind, body, and spirit. This bonding that occurs through yoga is said to bring about not only physical benefits but mental benefits as well, taking the individual to a level that could not be reached by manipulating one factor alone. This unique characteristic has prompted many back pain patients to incorporate yoga as part of their treatment program.

Yoga Day not only getting the pride of place in the National Capital and other cities in India, but it has also made an impact all over the world. An extravaganza called Yoga reached every nook and corner of the world and it was a significant success for the movement. Even monsoon rains did not lower the spirits of the people in Mumbai. The organisers have made an elaborate arrangement to conduct the memorable proceedings indoors to the convenience of the people and to make the yoga day a grand success.

We hope that the Yoga Day will be kicked off with a massive yoga demonstration and people from all walks of life will join Yogpath for robust health. Across India, the celebrations will go a long way in kindling the spirits of yoga practitioners. PM Modi made it a memorable day and the people did follow him in the true spirit of yoga to make Yoga Day an eventful one. Yoga is part and parcel of your life and that was displayed in a well-disciplined manner all through the year and the nation now follow it made a big stride in reaching the people through Yoga.

Anxiety, tension, brokenness, conditional love, death, dejection, emptiness, insignificance, guilt, hopelessness, illness, falsehood, and a sense of shame on the failure or due to shameless act by colleagues creates suicidal tendency. Depression is a strong mood involving sadness, loneliness, discouragement, despair or hopelessness that lasts for weeks, months or ever for a longer period creates the guilty feelings.

Over 18 million people suffer from depression every year. Many never seek treatment yet most cases of depression or treatable with effective therapies and medication. The best medicine is to mediate through yoga and win your heart and soul work according to your commands and not to give scope for diversions. Yoga plays a pivotal role and the essence of what you learnt through yoga comes handy when a person handles sadness or a sensitive issue with a mind to face any situation. There lies the success of Yoga and Yogis and now common people follow the better way to live a cheerful and happy life.


Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the author. The facts and opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of AFTERNOON VOICE and AFTERNOON VOICE does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Letters to the Editor: 20 June, 2019

FEATURE LETTER DIARY 679x400 e1553672678487

Don’t attack doctors

Doctors calling off their week long strike across the country comes as a relief. Doctors too are human and can commit mistakes but violence serves no purpose and there are proper forums as well as courts to address the grievances. Patients’ relatives should not take the law in their hands as the medical field is most important as lakhs of people across the country are treated successfully by these doctors who are saviours for many.

Also, doctors on their part too should not go on flash strikes as we are a nation of over a billion population with poor doctor-patient ratio and many deaths have take place in the country for want of treatment the last few days. Medical is a noble profession and we must respect the sanctity of this profession which saves several lives each year. Every public hospital should be provided with security by state governments so that untoward incidents which cause serious damage can be avoided.

S.N. Kabra

 

Serious folly of Education Board

Sage ‘Sushrut’ is the father of surgery. In English medium Bal Bharati’s text book for 6th standard of Maharashtra State Bureau of Textbook Production and Curriculum, he has been referred to as a veterinary doctor. This is being taught to students since 2016. So, wrong information has been spread among students but how can such serious mistakes be committed by the Education Board? Which data was used to refer to him as veterinary doctor?  Who has committed such mistake? Everyone needs to know it. It is not the first time that Maharashtra Education Board has committed mistakes but it would be long list of mistakes if it is noted down on paper. Similar is the situation with Central Education Board’s text books. This is a case of not just dissemination of wrong information but it is taxing people’s money since new text books have to be printed emptying Government’s coffers. Why shouldn’t such loss be recovered from the concerned irresponsible persons? It should be checked that a person appointed as an expert for preparing text book, is a true expert and does not hold degrees on paper and whether he is ignorant of knowledge of concerned subject. Special attention needs to be paid for distorting historical facts.          

 Kishor Auti

 

Archaic oath taking ceremony

The recent oath taking ceremony for the 17th Lok Sabha session witnessed several members affirming in different regional languages while assuming the position. The day long event witnessed all the members reading the transcript of the oath presented in the presence of pro-tem speaker.

Though the event witnessed many first time members setting foot at legislators into the Parliament, the entire day was merely wasted without any business. The day was reserved only for an oath taking ceremony, which holds no relevance in today’s busy world and thus only resulted in wastage of tax payers money for one day without any business. The archaic oath reading ceremony could have been replaced by mere signing of the papers through necessary Parliamentary business procedures and the session could have started off directly through business proceedings from day one itself.

As there many crucial amendment bills pending to be passed, which requires sufficient time for necessary discussions and then pass the resolution, the Hon’ble Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs is now suggested to look into taking off unwarranted and archaic oath taking ceremony for the members in both the houses and help ensure that sufficient time is given to discuss the issues which the voters are eagerly awaiting to witness.

Varun Dambal

 

Scholarship to minority students

It refers to central government announcing five crore scholarships to students from minority community with 50-per cent reserved for girls. Since the move is clubbed with proper training for Madarsa-teachers to bring them in main streamline, it seems to be a strategic step because till now Madrasas had been providing old faulty style of teaching young Muslim children of school-age. With Madrasas also providing future education in tune with other educational institutions, it will create homogeneous next generation through similar education-style.

It is noteworthy that for the first time, it has been clarified that minority communities other than Muslims will also be covered in scholarship-programme for minority students. Otherwise till now mainly Muslim-community were provided benefits through such special schemes launched for benefit of minority community.

Subhash Chandra Agrawal


(The views expressed by the author in the article are his/her own.)
Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Curtail Crony Capitalism — Part I

coronaru capitalism
Image Courtesy: economictimes.com

Crony capitalism kills transparency and competition and hence, it is harmful to free enterprise, opportunity, and economic growth. By killing transparency and competition, crony capitalism is harmful to free enterprise, opportunity, and economic growth. In crony capitalism, where the rich and the influential are alleged to have received land, natural resources and spectrum in return for payoffs to venal politicians. Thus, the rich is becoming richer and the poor remains poorer.

The greatest dangers to growth of developing economies like India is the middle income trap where crony capitalism – creates oligarchies that slow down the growth. The only way of avoiding this trap is to strengthen public services, especially those for the poor, adding that financial inclusion drive of the government and the RBI is a key initiative in the same direction. Crony capitalism hampers economic growth and needs to be taken care to prevent and clear the hurdle for greater transparency in the day to day transactions.

Ideological labels like ‘crony capitalism’ are likely to mislead by channelling the debate into philosophical-ideological issues of capitalism and socialism and detract from finding and addressing the real problems. The real problem is the unprecedented and unique system of government controls built under the Indian version of socialism. This has resulted in pervasive and deep-rooted corruption. We need policy reforms that reduce the incentive for corruption and institutional reforms that catch, try and punish the corrupt.

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. Having forgotten the license-permit-quota-raj that enveloped us from 1950 to 1980 and its crony socialism, many intellectuals, media persons and politicians have now discovered crony capitalism. The license raj consisted of stifling controls imposed on prices, production, capacity, investment, imports and exports, capital markets, banking and finance, land, labour. This provided ample opportunities for collusion between a corrupt government initially used to generate money to run parties and fight elections, but gradually became a means of generating personal income and wealth.

A new opportunity for corruption in public contracting has arisen in the form of Public-Private Partnership (PPP) contracts. Given the limited experience in this area, initial contracts had flaws that could create opportunities for corruption. There is now sufficient experience of PPP in ‘natural monopoly’ infrastructure, to modify these contracts and build corrective mechanisms into them. Governments have also failed to build independent professional regulatory systems.

During his election campaign in 2013-14, Modi raised expectations of a great economic revival, high growth, and tens of millions of new jobs for the ever-growing workforce. The new government hit the ground running and the first two years were action-packed and raised high hopes. There was temporary slow down after initial pick up and it gained momentum on the eve of 2019 general elections. We could praise the Modi government on maintaining economic growth at over 7 per cent (although the latest data shows slowing growth, especially in the already stressed agriculture sector), we could praise the government for bringing down inflation and keeping it low, and we could praise it for maintaining fiscal discipline by and large, letting it slip only due to political desperation as elections approached.


(The views expressed by the author in the article are his/her own.)
Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Dharmendra joins Horror comedy Khalli Balli

Khalli Balli,Dharmendra,rajpal yadav rajniesh duggalWriter-Director Manoj Sharma has just roped in yesteryear superstar Dharmendra in his Horror comedy film Khalli Balli produced by Kamal Kishor Mishra of One Entertainment Film Productions and Prachi Movies.

Dharmendra will be playing the role of Psychiatrist in the film. The film also stars Roja girl Madhoo, Kainaat Arora, Rajniesh Duggal, Rajpal Yadav, Vijay Raaj, Ekta Jain, Yasmeen Khan, Brijendra Kala, Yogesh Lakhani and Asrani. The film will be shot in Mumbai and Lucknow.

Violence against doctors is a heinous crime

Doctors protest in west bengal

As I see it!

Harakiri is not a new word. The great Kalidas is infamous for cutting the same branch of the tree on which he was sitting.

The society has not learnt its lessons, cutting the same lifeline on which its life is dependent. Ironical as it may seem, it is not astonishing! If as a society we had the wisdom, we would not have had a “Nirbhaya” every day in some corner of our house. We wouldn’t have been tolerating the corrupt system without a protest, accepting it as a norm of life; we wouldn’t be aspiring for civil services because it could fetch huge dowry and a lifetime of free corrupt money. We wouldn’t have voted for corrupt politicians and by now risen above the caste and religious line, to become only Indians!

Well, Mamata Banerjee is on back foot now. However, I guess, being what rubbish she is known for, she will retaliate at some later date. It’s not easy to be magnanimous and swallow your ego! A street fighter is never!

Today the politicians will yield, but tomorrow the same will be repeated. It’s difficult for the generally noble doctors (read any intellectual) to regroup again and again. So, it is important that this time when the movement is pan India, it should be with both long and short term objectives. We may not be in a similar advantageous situation as we are. The injury of our brothers in Kolkata will go down the drain and the public will have to suffer again and again. Let us pressurise the govt to the maximum.

This is the first time when the doctors have refused closed door meeting. Kudos my young brothers and sisters! You deserve applause!

Now it is all transparent. Cheers!

The politicians cannot coerce or lure the representatives and it has happened in so many previous strikes that suddenly the strikes were called off after a closed door meeting.

I think…

  1. Violence against the doctors or any healthcare personnel should be considered a heinous crime and a central Law should be formulated. Additionally, Government should provide police forces/CRPF Forces to protect the doctors and also run TV and media campaigns to inform the public.
  2. I think we should also somehow make use of this opportunity to remove Medical fraternity from consumer forum. No other professional comes under this preview, then why only a doctor. If anyone has any issue, he or she can use the existing laws to address their problems.

When the government treats the patient as a Consumer and Doctor as a service provider, where is the Bond of purity between the patient and the doctor? It is the root cause of all the problems and rising cost of health care. This must end! Sanctity must be restored.

Every single doctor treats about 10 patients free every month. It all goes down the drain because some Idiot files a case in consumer forum!

Also, we waste about Rs 20,000 or more amount (on an average) per year of our savings to protect ourselves due to this nonsense act.

  1. This system of registration renewal: Again, why only for doctors! Is it not discriminatory?

And we have to pay from our own pocket to attend the CMEs. If the Medical council wants us to renew every five years, isn’t it their duties to provide FREE CMEs which are relevant to every speciality!

Dear friends, it is just that we have been taken for granted. If we have risen today, better not to succumb but fight tooth and nail. Because time is a treacherous commodity! It may not be on your side always!

The General public is sympathetic and understands our plight. However, we can’t strike again and again! Not ethical.

(The author of the article is a renowned Plastic Surgeon practising in Mumbai.)


Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the author. The facts and opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of AFTERNOON VOICE and AFTERNOON VOICE does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Parliament suffers from Lord Rama vs Allah feud

BJP, parliament, Narendra Modi, Congress, Parliament crisis of Ram vs Allah, Hindu, MuslimsWhen All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul-Muslimeen (AIMIM) President Asaduddin Owaisi moved to take oath in the Parliament on Tuesday, he was greeted with slogans of “Vande Mataram”, “Jai Shri Ram” and “Bharat Mata Ki Jai.” Owaisi waved at the BJP legislators and asked them to chant the slogans loudly. After the conclusion of the oath-taking ceremony, Owaisi responded “Jai Bheem Jai Meem, Takbeer Allahu Akbar, and Jai Hind.”

Congress MLC Anant Gadgil said, “Whenever a new member is elected into the Parliament, and he takes oath as an MP, his/her religious, caste, and political backgrounds are insignificant. By chanting religious slogans, BJP is displaying their communal attitude. Whenever a new member joins the Parliament, we welcome him and don’t see his political background.”

When asked about the sloganeering in the Lok Sabha, Owasi replied that it was good that they remember such things when they see him. He said, “I hope they also remember the Constitution and the deaths of children in Muzaffarpur.” Until now, the chanting of ‘Jai Shri Ram’ and ‘Bharat Mata Ki Jai’ used to happen on the streets but now it has started happening in the Parliament too. Is Parliament a place to chant slogans like ‘Jai Shri Ram’ and Takbeer Allahu Akbar?

CPI (M) leader Ajit Abhyankar said, “Chanting religious slogans like ‘Jai Shri Ram’ and ‘Allahu Akbar’ in the Parliament is not right. This is what BJP wants. They want to divide the Parliament and it is a very sad day for the supreme legislative body of the Republic of India. Both Owaisi and BJP are dividing the Parliament on the basis of religion.”

The Modi government after coming back to power had called on newly elected members from the Muslim community to win their trust. The government also had coined the slogan “Sabka Saath Sabka Vikas” in an attempt to pave the way for inclusive development of the nation. However, when BJP legislators chanted the slogan “Jai Shri Ram”, Prime Minister Narendra Modi chose to remain silent.

When AV spoke to BJP MP Gopal Shetty, the recently elected MP from the Mumbai North constituency said, “The Parliament is the temple of the country and nationalistic feelings will be evoked there only. It’s better if ‘Jai Shri Ram’ is not chanted in the Parliament. However, Owaisi should recite ‘Allahu Akbar’ in Masjid and we will chant ‘Jai Shri Ram’ in the temple but ‘Bharat Mata Ki Jai’ should be chanted in the Parliament.”

What message are PM Modi and the BJP MPs trying to give by chanting these slogans in the Parliament? At least they could have maintained some decorum in the house as they are people’s representatives. People had voted for the BJP government with high expectations. However, if the newly elected members behave in such a manner, then they are only setting a wrong precedent in Parliament. Netizens took to Twitter to condemn the incident.

Rifat Jawaid tweeted, “This is extremely worrying when an MP is booed with provocative slogans inside the Parliament, the temple of democracy. This is shameful to say at least. These BJP MPs are doing a great disservice to their religion.”

Salman Nizami, another Twitter user tweeted, “BJP’s ‘Jai Shri Ram’ and Owaisi’s ‘Allahu Akbar’ – both are communal bigots doing politics on the blood of poor and innocent Hindu/Muslims. What has Owaisi done for the Muslims? What has BJP done for the Hindus? Drama Baaz. Shame on them.”

Another twitter user Shweta Hiya Chatterjee tweeted, “Such a disgrace to Indians. Never hd I imagined that I would have to watch such hooligans being elected as MP. Jai Shri Ram, Allahu Akbar, Jai Maa Kaali, such communalism & circus in the parliament. #DeathOfDemocracy has been declared.”

Zainaab Sikander tweeted, “To all MPs who tweeted Jai Shri Ram & to Asaduddin Owaisi sab who said takbeer. Congratulations for making an utter mockery out of the decorum of Parliament. The parliament is not to show off your religion be it “saffron” or “green”.

Earlier the furore over ‘Jai Shri Ram’ started in West Bengal after Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee lost her cool when a group of men chanted ‘Jai Shri Ram’ as her convoy was passing through Bhatpara area in North 24 Parganas district. Mamata Banerjee had allegedly objected to uttering of the slogan ‘Jai Shri Ram’ during multiple incidents.

Asaduddin Owaisi’s AIMIM had an alliance with Prakash Ambedkar’s Bharipa Bahujan Mahasangh for contesting the Lok Sabha polls. However, the alliance failed to make a dent in BJP-Shiv Sena’s vote in Maharashtra. In the recent Lok Sabha polls, Owaisi won in his home ground by a margin of 2,82,186 votes against BJP’s Dr. Bhagwanth Rao.

Indian politics divided into Mandir (Temple) and Masjid (Mosque)

When the Parliamentarians were taking oath on Tuesday, they forgot that they are bounded by the Constitution and its laws and moreover, they are in the house to serve the people; however, displaying of their religious beliefs — from ‘Allahu Akbar’ to ‘Jai Shri Ram’ to ‘Jai Maa Kali’ — was too dramatic, vague, and deliberate. This behaviour has disappointed many voters like me who have chosen the government or the MPs irrespective of their political parties, with the great faith of development and betterment of this country.

The entire Parliament is divided into Mandir and Masjid politics; secularism has become a slang with changed electoral equations. Since the 2014 election, swelling Hindu nationalism has put the opposition parties and secularism on the back foot. Many Indian intellectuals have clinched that the BJP is now the new custodian of Indian politics and nationalism.

The growing unanimity seems to be that Hindu jingoism has gained power at the cost of secularism to the point of being viewed as the only authentic stance an electorally successful nationwide political party can take.

The attitude of the Congress Party lends itself to such an interpretation too, at least up to a point, as the party at times has sought to downplay its secularist roots and embrace pro-Hindu sentiments.

When Congress has realised that the Hindu votes are sliding from them, they indulged in what some observers derisively have called “soft Hindutva,” emulating the kind of religiosity that is typically associated with the BJP. During the state election campaigns in Gujarat (2017) as well as Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan (2018), Rahul Gandhi took the unusual step (for him) of visiting dozens of temples. He presented himself as a Shiv Bhakt by sporting Chandan Tilaka on his forehead, his sister too indulged in doing Abhishek to Mahakal.

Rahul displayed his Janevu (a sacred thread worn by the upper caste Hindu males), and let his support discuss his Brahmin background as well as his Gotra (clan) in response to the BJP leaders who repeatedly brought up the Italian heritage of his mother, former Congress Party president Sonia Gandhi. Well, in the state elections, they performed very well but when it comes to electing the PM, the same thing did not go well with Congress.

On the other hand, Modi is these days very soft on Muslims and trying his level best in appeasing them. In this Hindu-Muslim tug of war politics, the main issue of building Ram Mandir in Ayodhya has taken a back seat and BJP is hell bent on coming back to this issue.

Beyond optics, Congress has begun flirting with some of the BJP’s favourite campaign themes. For instance, the party manifesto in Madhya Pradesh promised to build Gaushalas (cow shelters), develop the commercial production of Gaumutra (cow urine), and cow dung — the former is used in traditional Hindu medicine while the latter is used as fuel or fertiliser; promote the Ram Van Gaman Path (the path that Lord Ram took during his exile from Ayodhya); pass laws that would conserve India’s sacred Rivers, and promote Sanskrit.

The deputy speaker of Madhya Pradesh Vidhan Sabha (state assembly) and manifesto committee chair admitted that the Congress was adopting this platform in response to BJP pressures. The BJP used to brand Congress as [a] Muslim party. It’s a conscious decision to shed that tag thrust on them by their rivals.

As a result, the Congress Party’s state manifesto differed vastly from the previous iteration issued in 2013. Five years ago, the party devoted a whole section to the “minority community,” (a reference mainly to Muslims), a section in which it promised to furnish special economic assistance for madrasas, a new law to curb communal violence, and the implementation of the Sachar Committee recommendations.

The Congress Party’s pro-Hindu trend is reinforced by the party’s strategy in terms of ticket distribution. In the 2014 general election, Congress party nominated only 27 Muslim candidates for the Lok Sabha elections, a paltry 5.6 per cent of its total candidates. Well, from 2014 to 2019, the politics was twisted in two religious groups, now minorities have no messiah and Hindus don’t like Congress; the changed narrative of Congress has damaged them to the core. In many BJP-ruled states, minorities have felt vulnerable because of the slayings of Muslims accused of harming cows and, to a lesser extent, the harassment of Christian priests or nuns.

Whether Congress-run state governments provide security to minorities and restore their trust in state institutions, including the police, will be an important measure of the party’s secular credentials. On this front, again, the situation varies from one Congress-ruled state to another, according to the capacity of state leaders to resist pressure from Hindu nationalists. The minorities have no national political party to look forward as Congress changed its stand.

Now coming back to the Ayodhya topic, the Congress is in a fix — if they support Babri and Muslim, they will get exposed over their Hindu stand, Janevu, and Gotra. If they don’t support Ram Temple, minorities will really dump them. It is the scenario with opposition party too, where Dalits are playing different politics. They as whole stood as a parallel politics with no inclination and no individual stand but fallback where they find gain. The Ayodhya affair is the best illustration of this dynamic.

After the Babri Masjid was destroyed in 1992, the Indian government appointed a one-man commission led by former Supreme Court justice Manmohan Singh Liberhan. The resulting report, which took 17 years to complete and whose contents were finally leaked to the media, assigned responsibility for the demolition of the mosque to clearly identified Hindu nationalist figures. To date, however, the judicial branch has not asked the government to table the report in the Parliament or to file charges. This delay suggests that trying Hindu nationalists, in this case, is seen as too electorally complex.


(Any suggestions, comments or dispute with regards to this article send us on feedback@www.afternoonvoice.com)

Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice