Home Blog Page 937

Mothers on rent, lucrative trade in India

Recently, there was a report on an illegal fertility clinic in Telangana discovered 47 surrogate mothers – who had been lured to rent their wombs for money – living in “terrible conditions”. Following a tip-off, Telangana state police raided the fertility clinic in the city of Hyderabad and discovered the women, nearly all from northeastern states. The women were all huddled in one large room and had access to just one bathroom. They were mostly migrants from northeastern states who had been brought here through agents and promised up to Rs 400,000. They were staying here as part of an agreement between the (adoptive) parent and the surrogate.

The surrogacy industry has come under attack from women’s rights groups who say such clinics are “baby factories” for the rich, and lack of regulation results in poor and uneducated women signing contracts they do not fully understand. These days, poor woman are adopting to such trade, they give birth to as good as ten children in ten years, yearly they earn 4 to 5 lakhs of rupees for their family, actually nothing doing much. The food, medication and living are provided by hospitals and in most of the cases, rich families personally take care of health hygiene of surrogated mothers. These mothers find this earning much more largely than the earnings they get out of doing domestic labour or field labour. They manage to make a small home, they manage some savings and some small work for themselves, an average one woman in five to ten years earns minimum 25 lakhs.

Such earnings are blessing for poverty stricken villagers. Moreover they feel this is a good karma job, as they become reason for someone’s happiness. Where as earlier many of these women were pushed to flesh trade, which was horrific life.

There has been a surge in demand for surrogates after the government drafted a bill to outlaw commercial surrogacy – a multi-billion dollar industry.

Right now, the surrogacy industry is anything goes, which is really scary. There was legislation proposed in India in 2010, it just hasn’t been passed. At the same time, there’s no limit to how many embryos can be implanted. Doctors have been known to insert more than one or two embryos to increase the chances that the woman will get pregnant without losing time or money. The commissioning couple may only want one baby, so sometimes, when more than one baby is born, the couple isn’t told, even though it’s their genetic offspring. Then these babies are offered from the black market. There are many foreign couples that adopt such children in whichever sum you ask for.

Until the ban on surrogacy passes, India continues to be among a handful of countries where women can be paid to carry another’s child through in-vitro fertilisation and embryo transfer. The demand is very high right now and the involvement of migrant workers coming down from the northeast to take up surrogacy is new.

For pro-nationalist countries, like India where children are highly desired, parenthood is culturally compulsory and childlessness is socially unacceptable, the Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ARTs) are rapidly globalising. Factors such as growth of infertility in modern society coupled with the rising demand for having one’s own child, adoption restrictions, the development of surrogacy contract and commercial surrogacy agencies has resulted in the increasing publicity and public interest in the formation of such agreements between infertile couples and surrogate mothers. A womb for rent is growing in India. There is no record for tracking the number of such pregnancies but doctors work with surrogates in almost all major cities. India has been regarded as the surrogacy capital of the world. Surrogacy business in India is estimated to be worth over Rs 2000 crore. Commercial surrogacy became legal in India since 2002. Here the total cost of having a baby through surrogacy is one-third of what it is in USA and other western countries. Moreover, the lack of regulation, Indian women being less prone to having smoking and drinking habits, the provision of enjoying the biological parent’s name in the birth certificate of the baby born, and the younger age of the surrogate mother holding a better chance of getting a successful pregnancy makes India a favoured destination for the intended parents. Surrogacy has risen from a position of shame to acceptance, need and means to survive. Commissioning couples from the U.S. and Europe use Indian surrogacy agencies because they’re as much as six times cheaper than Western alternatives.

Surrogacy companies claim to offer opportunities for women to escape poverty, promoting international surrogacy as a win-win for everyone involved. There are cases where American couples feel a little strange about what is happening, and the ethics of it, but turn a blind eye because they don’t want to pay the higher rates in the states. Many couples don’t want to know what’s behind the scenes, they want their baby fast, and they want it done cheaply. At the same time, there are couples that have an ongoing relationship with the surrogate and are very involved in making sure she’s making a choice and not simply being exploited. In spite of this industry having very dark side, it’s been bigger business in India and mother’s are restlessly milling babies.


(Any suggestions, comments or dispute with regards to this article send us on feedback@www.afternoonvoice.com)

Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Empowerment of Rural Women – Part I

Rural Women Empowerment, Women Empowerment, Rural women, women ,rural areas, women educationPandit Jawaharlal Nehru had once said, “You can tell the condition of a nation by looking at the status of its women”. 15th October was celebrated as International day of Rural women. The crucial role that women and girls play in ensuring the sustainability of rural households and communities, improving rural livelihoods and overall wellbeing, has been increasingly recognized. Women account for a substantial proportion of the agricultural labour force, including informal work, and perform the bulk of unpaid care and domestic work within families and households in rural areas.

Women used to command acute power and importance in our ancient culture. The proof of this fact can be found in all the scriptures and even our mythological stories. We worship Goddess Durga, Lakshmi, Saraswati and many others. That shows how Indian civilisation had revered the female form.

Climate change affects women’s and men’s assets and well-being differently in terms of agricultural production, food security, health, water and energy resources, climate-induced migration and conflict, and climate-related natural disasters.

Women are powerful change agents to address climate change at scale. They are key actors in building community resilience and responding to climate-related disasters. Women tend to make decisions about resource use and investments in the interest and welfare of their children, families, and communities.

Empowerment of women involves many things – economic opportunity, social equality, and personal rights. Women are deprived of these human rights, often as a matter of tradition. In rural areas, women are generally not perceived to have any meaningful income generation capacity, and hence, they are relegated mainly to household duties and cheap labour.

At the same time, we cannot just brush aside women empowerment as a policy provided it is aimed at arming the poor and the uninitiated. In India, most of the action takes place in the rural areas because India is predominantly rural. Women are simply male appendages mainly because of the feudal characteristic of life there. The laws remain only in the statute book. They are seldom invoked.

The social legislation can be effective only when there is corresponding awareness among women.

There are signs of women pursuing things after their heart. But, they need catalysts. But the question of whether the catalysts should be in the nature of public spirited men or legal fiats or both depends upon the peculiar circumstances obtaining in each pocket.

(This is the first part of the article and the remaining portion will continue tomorrow)


(The views expressed by the author in the article are his/her own.)Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Letters to the Editor: 15 October, 2019

letters to the editor, afternoon voice,Wriddhiman Saha was brilliant behind stumps 

South Africa was easy meat for the Indians as they succumbed to an innings and 137 runs loss in the Pune Test to lose the series 2-0 with one Test remaining. It has been a dream run for Virat Kohli under whose leadership our country has won 30 games in 50 test matches he has captained. The star performer surprisingly in the Pune Test was wicketkeeper Wriddhiman Saha who was brilliant behind the stumps and some of the catches were out of the blue. Wriddhiman is perhaps the best keeper in the world at the moment and Team India should pursue with him in all formats of the game.

Kohli and his boys have been performing consistently except for our World Cup ODI loss in England and our next goal should be to win the T-20 World Cup next year. India should give youngsters a chance in the 3rd Test now that we have won the series. South Africa will face a white wash and they will have to put a respectable show to avoid that humiliation

S.N. Kabra

 

A big salute to Pranjal Patil

The true life story of Pranjal Patil, the country’s first visually challenged woman IAS officer, is something that gives everyone the young and the old a very big lesson -nothing is impossible if one has  the will power, perseverance, steadfastness  and a focussed determination to overcome all odds. This
young woman battled great odds in her life to achieve what she truly aspired for, to write the civil service examination, pass the civil service and become an IAS officer. She has now become the Sub-Collector  of Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala .

The loss of vision at the age of six did not deter the young girl from Ulhasnagar, Maharashtra, from pursuing her civil service dream. In 2016, she cracked the Union Public Services Examination on her very first attempt with a rank of 773. Though she was refused a job in the Indian Railway Accounts Service on the grounds that she was visually challenged  Pranjal  didn’t bow down and instead  pursued to have her big dream come true. In her second attempt the very next year the youngster improved her ranking. Securing the 124th rank in the 2017 Civil Services Exams, she was posted as Assistant Collector in Ernakulam, Kerala, in 2018 and now  has  been appointed as the sub collector thus becoming the first visually challenged woman in the country to attain such a high post. The adage “where there is a will there is a way ” comes cent per cent true in the case of this young IAS officer. A big salute to her.

M Pradyu

 

Negligence caused fire mishap

It is most unfortunate that Mumbai city is facing a series of fire accidents causing death of human life and property as well. In a latest fire in the Grant Road, a 22 year old died and six others including two fire fighters suffered breathing problem in the blaze that broke out in a ground plus four storey commercial building on a Sunday morning. This is one more case of negligence causing a fire mishap in the heart of city. The fire audit is not done on many building causing such serious fire accidents. Weekend workload on electrical gadgets operated continuously without being switched off on Friday is the cause for fire accidents. Carefree attitude of authorities before closing the office is the major reason. It is time to exercise caution and make sure that the electrical gadgets are put off before pulling down the shutters so that mishaps of such nature can be avoided. Fire fear in high rise building is a cause of worry these days.

C.K.S. Gundu Maniam


(The views expressed by the author in the article are his/her own.)Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Koregaon Bhima case: Bombay High Court refuses bail to three civil liberties activists

Bombay High Court iStockThe Bombay High Court on Tuesday refused bail to civil liberties activists Sudha Bharadwaj, Arun Ferriera and Vernon Gonsalves, arrested for allegedly inciting caste-based violence at Koregaon Bhima in Pune and having links with Maoists.

Justice Sarang Kotwal rejected the bail pleas filed by the three activists. The accused were initially placed under house arrest in August last year by the Pune Police in Maharashtra and were later taken into custody on October 26, after a sessions court in Pune rejected their bail pleas. The activists, who have been in jail since then, approached the high court last year.

The police have booked the three accused and several other activists under provisions of the stringent Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act and the Indian Penal Code.

The case was lodged against them in January 2018 after the Elgar Parishad, held on December 31, 2017, that allegedly triggered violence at Koregaon-Bhima village in Pune the next day.

The police alleged that the accused had links with Maoists and were working towards overthrowing the government.

The three accused, however, claimed there was no evidence to support the police case that they and other activists were creating a ‘war-like’ situation against the government.

Campaign at peak in Maharashtra as only five days left

Sharad pawar, narendra modi, raj thackeray, aaditya thackeray, rahul gandhi, uddhav thackeray, devendra fadnavis, prakash ambedkar, MNS, Shiv Sena, BJP, Congress, NCP, Maharashtra elections, Elections campaign, maharashtra elections 2019, campaign, elections, maharashtra assembly elections, assembly elections 2019, elections rally, prime minister, chief minister,As date of voting approaching near, election campaign reaches its peak across Maharashtra. The campaign will come to stand still on October 19. Thus, only five days are left for political leaders to put their points to voters of the state. Therefore, leaders of ruling and opposition parties are trying to leave no stone unturned in this election to connect with voters. The schedule of every leader is very busy. They have no time for proper food and sleep. Maharashtra will go to polls on October 21. Counting of votes will be held on October 24 and results will be declared the same day.

When our correspondent Nikhil Sagare spoke to Former Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan he said, “Congress candidates are campaigning in their respective constituency. Central level leaders too are expected to join campaigning. Rahul Gandhi has started campaigning in Maharashtra and Congress will derive benefit out of it.”

Prime Minister, Chief Minister, ministers, former chief ministers and senior leaders from all the political parties are holding and addressing meetings and rallies to lure the voters. Chief Ministers of BJP-ruled states are also campaigning in Maharashtra. On Sunday, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and former Congress president Rahul Gandhi addressed election rallies. PM Modi addressed rallies in Jalgaon and Sakoli. On October 16, PM will address three rallies at Akola, Partur (Jalna district) and Panvel (Navi Mumbai). He will hold election meetings in Satara, Pune and Parli on October 17. PM Modi will address a grand public meeting in Mumbai on October 18. Rahul Gandhi addressed his first rally in the state. He addressed two rallies in Mumbai in Dharavi and Chandivali. Congress leader also addressed a rally at Ausa in Latur district.

Samajwadi Party leader Abu Azmi said, “Samajwadi party is working for the upliftment of downtrodden. Those who are creating a rift between Hindus and Muslims are a threat to the nation’s security. The economy of the country is witnessing a slump, unemployment has increased.”

On Monday, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis held meetings in Amravati, Washim and Yavatmal districts, while Shiv Sena chief Uddhav Thackeray held  seven meetings in Osmanabad and Solapur districts. MNS President Raj Thackeray held meetings in Yavatmal and Pune districts. President of NCP Sharad Pawar held meetings in Kannada and Vaijapur in Aurangabad and Shegaon and Kopargaon in Ahmednagar district. Prakash Ambedkar addressed four meetings in Parbhani, Jalna and Aurangabad districts. Asaduddin Owaisi also addressed a meeting in Bhiwandi.

Shiv Sena spokesperson Dr Manisha Kayande said, “The manifesto of Shiv Sena is publicised by us. Candidates who are contesting for the first time are meeting people by doing door to door campaigning. Shiv Sena is focused on this. Uddhav and Aditya Thackeray are holding 3 to 4 political rallies in a day. Aditya Thackeray while campaigning in Worli is touring all over Maharashtra too. Shiv Sena is expected to win more than 100 seats.”

It is worth mentioning that the BJP and the Sena alliance is seeking second term in the assembly elections, while the opposition Congress-NCP are contesting polls to make a comeback to power. The BJP-Shiv Sena alliance and the Congress-NCP coalition are locked in tough fights. Many small parties are also fighting elections for the spoils. The MNS of Raj Thackeray, AIMIM, Vanchit Bahujan Aghadi, Swabhimani Shetkari Sanghatna are prominent in this list.

NCP Mumbai president and spokesperson Nawab Malik said, “Candidates are having door to door conversation with people. Sitting MLAs have not performed their job well. Inflation, farmer suicides, unemployment has increased. Sharad Pawar’s rallies are getting good response from public. This time there will be a change in governance.”

According to the Election Commission of India, elections for the 288 assembly seats in the state will be held at 96,661 polling stations on October 21. Over 8.9 crore voters are the expected to cast their votes. Total 3,239 candidates are in the fray. 1,79,895 ballot units and 1,26,505 control units will be used. For the first time VVPAT (voter verifiable paper audit trail) machines will be used in Maharashtra assembly elections. 1,35,021 VVPAT machines will be used across the state.

BJP national vice-president Vinay Sahasrabuddhe said, “Every possible effort is made to reach out to voters. Campaigning is being done to attract new voters. We are not leaving any stone unturned to connect with voters. Modi and Amit Shah are senior leaders and their campaigning will definitely help us. Our party is expected to win 75 per cent seats out of 164.”

Every 50 seconds parents in India kill their daughter – Part III

Planned Parenthood’s abortionists sometimes do a manual version to keep the baby’s head intact so it can be sold. The baby is delivered feet first and killed in the process. This is, of course, akin to an illegal partial-birth abortion. The fetal soup sold in China is nauseating to any normal human being, but are Planned Parenthood’s actions any less so? In China, the only people responsible for this human cannibalism are the paying customers themselves. But in the United States, because of the huge subsidies that Planned Parenthood receives from the American taxpayer, we are all “paying customers.”

According to Planned Parenthood’s FY 2013-2014 annual report, the supposedly non-profit organisation received a whopping $528 million. The US taxpayer is the single largest contributor to Planned Parenthood, providing some 41 per cent of its total revenue. Planned Parenthood committed 327,653 abortions in the FY 2013-2014, an estimated one-third of all abortions committed in the US that year. To put this number into perspective, Planned Parenthood abortionists are stopping a beating heart 37 times every hour, night and day, week after week, month after month. And there is another reason why we can make no claims of moral superiority over China. Unlike the People’s Republic, we are a democratic country. We elected the men to Congress who appropriated our money and gave it to abortionists like Nucatola. We elected the President—Barack Obama—who keynotes Planned Parenthood fundraising events. So we are all—collectively—responsible for doing something about Planned Parenthood’s dirty business.

Because of its trafficking in baby body parts, Planned Parenthood is already under investigation by the US House of Representatives and in several States, including Georgia, Indiana, Louisiana, Ohio, and Texas.

India may be little different, they may not be eating or doing any business on unborn babies but one thing is sure still the girl child is most unwanted and they are forced to get killed. There are 21 million “unwanted” girls in India due to parents favouring having sons instead of daughters, new government figures show. Released as part of India’s annual economic survey, the 2017-2018 estimate found that many couples had a “son preference” and would keep having children until they had a boy. Furthermore, the data estimated that there are 63 million women “missing” from India’s population — with 2 million more from every age group going “missing” every year — because the desire for sons has given rise to sex-selective abortions, and girls suffer disproportionately from disease, neglect, or inadequate nutrition. Economic and cultural reasons such as property passing on to sons rather than daughters, paying for a wedding dowry, and daughters moving to their husband’s house, all contribute to a preference for boys.

The situation on girl child has improved by leaps and bounds compared to even fifty years ago. Is a girl child completely accepted in the society? Not yet, but as years go by, improvement is a sure thing.

Why a girl child is not wanted? The base answer, I believe, is money. Once upon a time, parents would give a part of their assets to their married daughters as a way to help them be independent. These assets would be passed down to the daughters’ children. As years passed, this division that was wholly by ‘choice’ twisted up to be by ‘force.’ The in-laws would demand the parents to give more and more to them. What was a way to making sure your daughter’s future remained safe, became bride-price or dowry.

As poverty increased, the pressure to give dowry if one had daughters was enormous causing them to start hating/ disliking girls. Thus, birth of a girl came to be seen as an unlucky’ star. Not something to be celebrated, but something to be mourned. This was all compounded by the fact that girl were not allowed to get education, not allowed to work and not allowed to earn money. Thus, maintaining girls became an extremely expensive affair for the parents.

How to change this? Through education, equal work opportunities and banning the concept of dowry. I believe, the current generation will lead towards a better future for girl children. I can say I am seeing this myself, personally. After marriage, my mother was not allowed to work and was forced to leave her job. She was told that divorce was not a choice to be made. However, she was the first one to tell me – “Slap any man who tells you to stop working and that you should sit at home and pop out kids. Me and your father have given you such good education, forced you to study so that you can be independent and have choices if anything happens to you, the way it happened to me.”


(Any suggestions, comments or dispute with regards to this article send us on feedback@www.afternoonvoice.com)

Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Dr. Kalam: A Social Scientist

Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam, Abdul Kalam, Dr. Kalam, Kalam, ISRO, father of isro, President, Abdul KalamThe remarkable contributions made by Iconic Dr APJ Abdul Kalam turn him a living legend for the entire country. Dr. Kalam has contributed significantly to social causes in India. From the very first day when Dr. Kalam became the 11th President of India on 25th July in 2002, he spearheaded a socio-economic development scheme of igniting the young minds with positive thoughts and of propagating the “Developed India by 2020”.

Dr. Kalam was a rare blend of brilliance, determination, foresight and humility. He believed that all people are equal and enjoy the same degree of humanity. Equality between people should be regardless their race, colours, creed and cultures. Dr. Kalam views that a society can make progress only when it gives equal opportunity to women in all walks of life. He was a supporter for women empowerment. According to him, women are equal partners in national development. He says: When women are empowered, a society with stability is assured. Women constitute the half of society. Women are the backbone to the development of a society.

Dr. Kalam was an educator par excellence and for whom sovereign boundaries did not matter when it comes to child’s education. He presented a humanist view of his personal, technological and social domains as mirror of the soul. He was of the opinion that Science is all about asking questions and finding the right answers through hard work and research into laws of nature. Science tries to provide solutions for a better material life, while spiritualism looks at answers on how to lead a righteous life. According to him, Science and spirituality seek the same divine blessings for doing well for the people.

Dr. Kalam had vision for a developed India which included doubling the present agricultural production with attendant food processing, capabilities, focusing an environmental protection and climate change mitigation, ensuring literacy, social security, and overall health and reducing the levels of poverty by encouraging the purchase of swadeshi goods.

PURA (Providing Urban Amenities in Rural Areas) is the major component of President’s dream for a developed India. PURA habitat design depends upon the development of infrastructures in every corner of rural India. PURA aims to provide knowledge connectivity through education, vocational training, and entrepreneurial training for farmers, craftsmen, etc. It also aims to improve healthcare and sanitation facilities in these village clusters.

Dr. Kalam was a visionary man. He saw a dream of India becoming a developed country by the year of 2020. He is a man of vision, who was always full of ideas aimed at the development of the country and is often also referred to as the Missile Man of India. People loved and respected Dr. Kalam so much during his tenure as President that he was popularly called the people’s President.

The visionary leadership style of Dr. Kalam implications for the guidance of new age leaders engaged in developmental tasks globally. He is a supporter of open source software over proprietary solutions and believes that its use on a large scale will bring the benefits of information technology to more people.

Dr. Kalam’s life, works and vision are truly a lesson for all of us. He is no more but his teaching and message should continue to inspire and influence our heart. He will be remembered as one of India’s greatest scientist, greatest educator, inspirer and visionary.

By Dr. Meraj Ahmad Meraj


(The views expressed by the author in the article are his/her own.)Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

Letters to the Editor: 14 October, 2019

letters to the editor, afternoon voice,It’s time to show respect to our pets and stray animals

We celebrated World Animal Day on October 4. I am sure some of us may not even be aware of this day. It is a reminder for us to treat our pets, and even stray animals with respect. But that’s not the case. If we look around on our highways, and even internal roads, all these are infested with stray cattle and dogs. That’s no way to show respect to these animals. It’s like we have disowned them. Animals enrich ourselves in ways we don’t even know.

Jubel D’Cruz

 

Take step to prevent suicides

It is high time the global community take serious of suicides and find immediate steps and execute actions so as to save  precious lives which otherwise sadly are  self destroyed. In India too the number of suicide cases are more than those  happening due to accidents. It is also alarming to note that according to a survey in India, suicide was the leading cause of death among teens and those in their 20s  and 30s. Suicides are committed irrespective of age and gender and the main factors that lead to such  shocking self destroying tendencies  is not only mental illness or depression but  also due to personal, economical and social issues which if  spotted, dealt and handled carefully  and diligently would save so many lives The government should  take necessary  steps so as NGOs, mental health organisations and institutions are given necessary support so as to at least make individuals in distress get convinced that they can open up and get immediate advice and help. This definitely to an extent can win the trust of individuals and prevent many from committing suicides. Educational institutions and welfare organisations can also do a vital role in this matter.

M Pradyu

 

Old wine in new bottle

Sena Manifesto is nothing new and it is once again old wine in new bottle. In fact after the authorities hacked over 2000 trees at the Aarey Milk Colony Metro car shed site, Sena Chief was vehement about catching the murderers of the trees. But in the manifesto there is no mention about Aarey and it was surprising. By promising Re 1 medical facility and ten rupee meals, the government exchequer will face finance crunch in the future. It is a matter of convenience for political parties to change their statement according to situation and the people are not going to be benefited with these false promises much.

Nikhil Maniam 

 

Stop mockery of poll process

It refers to data that a vast majority of 86-per cent candidates in 2019-elections to Lok Sabha lost security-deposits. Most of security-losing candidates know themselves even before filing nominations that they would be losing security. Many of such candidates are either vote-splitters or file nominations in hope of getting money from rival candidates to withdraw names in favour. Such mockery of poll-process must be stopped by making it one of the measures for much-needed and most awaited massive and consolidated poll-reform. Also all those getting votes less than NOTA should be disqualified for life to contest any election. Such a provision may pave way for an ideal two-party system which is essential for healthy democratic system.

A sitting MLA, MLC or MP must resign first from earlier seat before filing nomination for other. An MP may automatically lose membership of Parliament on taking oath as minister in a state. Likewise any state-legislator may lose membership on taking oath as minister at the centre. Legislators in states and centres may be disqualified for contesting elections for life in case of mid-term resignation from the legislative body. State-legislators and Parliamentarians must not be allowed to hold membership of civic bodies in tune with one-person one-post norm. Likewise elected representatives must not be allowed to hold party-posts simultaneously.

Madhu Agrawal


(The views expressed by the author in the article are his/her own.)Help Parallel Media, Support Journalism, Free Press, Afternoon Voice

No child in pre-school should be made to take written or oral test: NCERT

NCERT, Pre-school, Oral test, test, child, student, school test
Image Courtesy: Economic Times

No child in pre-school should be made to give any written or oral exam, the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) has said, terming it as a harmful and undesirable practice resulting from misguided parental aspiration.

According to the Council which is the HRD Ministry’s curriculum developing body, the purpose of evaluation at the pre-school stage is not to label a child as “pass” or “fail”.

“On no account, should children be made to take any form of test or examination either oral or written. The purpose of evaluation at the pre-school stage is not to label a child as ‘pass’ or ‘fail’,” a senior NCERT official said.

“Currently we have in the country, pre-school programmes ranging from those that put children to a dull and monotonous routine to those where children are exposed to structured formal learning, often in English, made to do tests and homework, and denied their right to play. These are undesirable further and harmful practice that results from misguided parental aspiration,” the official added.

The NCERT has listed do’s and dont’s on how assessment should be carried out and reported in pre-schools as part of its “guidelines for pre-school education”.

“Each child’s progress needs to be assessed on a continuous basis using different tools and techniques such as anecdotal records, checklists, portfolios and interactions with other children.

“The teacher should make brief written notes based on observations of children – how and where children spend time, their social relationships, use of language, modes of interaction, information about health and nutrition habits.

“Each child’s folder should be available for parents and children to view and should remain with the preschool until such time as a child’s transition to another preschool programme or in the primary school. All parents should receive a written and verbal progress summary report of their child at least twice a year,” the guidelines read.

The guidelines have also defined parameters for infrastructure, qualifications and salary for preschool staff, admission process and records and registers to be maintained, monitoring and supervision mechanism and importance of coordination and convergence with community and parents.

 

Will Supreme Court consider equal distribution of assets of husband and wife

Supreme Court of India, Supreme CourtAdv. Pratibha Bangera (Advocate and legal Expert in Divorce and Family law) stresses need for having guidelines for maintenance with our Editor-in-chief Dr Vaidehi Taman.

What does the statue say about maintenance in family matters?

Maintenance is a right of a married dependent spouse who does not have his or her own independent source of income. While the husband can ask for maintenance under any of the applicable law, it is also the duty of the husband to maintain his wife and children. Especially if the wife does not have an independent source of income.

What if the wife is a working woman is she still entitled to get maintenance?

A working woman is also entitled to get maintenance especially if she is taking care of the marital household and the children born from the marriage.

What is the biggest hurdle in maintenance cases these days?

There are no fixed Supreme Court guidelines on computation of income. While it is easy to establish a salaried person’s income and also attach property of husband’s assets if he owns it, the business man may manipulate his income and asset and show losses and this is the most challenging issue these days. Most importantly it is done to force the wife to agree for divorce in bargain. Till date there is no criterion or yardstick on how such amounts should be calculated uniformly all over the country. The disparity of income classes in the country has further made it difficult while deciding cases. While the very poor and affluent are standing before the same judge, decisions are made upon circumstances of the case and not the actual income capacity of the spouse or his capacity to pay.

Does duration of marriage make any difference to the amount granted by court?

Not really. If the husband has a source of income which can be proven (shown by husband) the wife may still win a good maintenance. The husband however can Appeal against any unjust order and ask for stay of such order and also ask for reduction of such amount granted.

What is interim maintenance amount granted by court?

The court takes into account duration of marriage, children born from such marriage, grounds on which the application for maintenance was filed, income of husband and similar factors and then passes decision. However there is acute need for such guidelines because lot of wives and mothers are waiting due to lack of court intervention even after order of maintenance is passed and are forced to apply for “distress warrant” to force the husband to pay by making him criminally liable to pay on time. Further the husbands may pay part of the amount of arrears and seek extension of time to pay the balance amount as most of the time such amounts are payable from date of filing of application. Since there are no strict guidelines to determine these amounts, or safeguard interest of the wife or even interest of the husband who may be innocent in some cases the need for guidelines is highest now,

Does the Indian woman feel victimized due to this?

The Supreme Court is likely to frame guidelines to establish “real income” as per “lifestyle and “standard of living” or “capacity” of the husband to pay. However there are no directions to lower court so far. A Reference Application to High court by any aggrieved wife may be required to be made to seek directions from Higher court or Supreme Court to give directions to lower court instead of taking matters for Appeal. These are matters which should be decided on highest priority.

How do husbands misuse and abuse process of law?

It is common practice to delay making payment on time or deny essentials such as rent or grocery or household essentials or also school fees in some cases. There are many such pending cases especially having a disturbing effect on the wife thereby driving her to such a point that she comes forth to settle matter as per conditions set by husband or agrees to settle for lesser amounts and agree to divorce.

Do women also misuse and abuse the legal system by making false claims? There have been classic cases where women have married and immediately filed repeated domestic violence cases with sole intention of extracting “alimony amount”. Even husband and family are sometimes scared and ashamed of such allegations and promptly pay off money to buy their peace of mind and give in to pressure tactics.

What about men who hide their income and refuse to pay the wife and children?

There is a likelihood that in future there may be mandatory guidelines to make it compulsory that all properties held by husband or wife may be considered as “marital property” and equally distributed among wife and children like it happens in several progressive countries. However this issue cannot resolve if the family in joint business in the affluent classes hide their real income and alienate the assets in jointly owned business. Supreme Court will have to consider this aspect because all businessmen communities in India operate in an entirely controlling fashion to deny supporting the “wife of their son”.