The growing misuse of Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code, originally enacted to protect women from cruelty and harassment, is a pressing concern that demands immediate legislative and judicial attention. The alarming trend of exploiting this provision to implicate not only husbands but also their extended families is causing untold harm and undermining the law’s intended purpose. While safeguarding women’s rights remains paramount, the unchecked misuse of such a potent legal tool must be addressed to maintain balance and fairness in the justice system.
A recent judgement by the Supreme Court in Dara Lakshmi Narayana & Others vs. State of Telangana & Another has once again highlighted this issue. Delivered on December 10, 2024, the Court strongly cautioned against the nefarious tendency to indiscriminately involve entire families in cases arising from matrimonial disputes. Such misuse of the law not only dilutes its efficacy but also destroys the lives of innocent individuals who are falsely accused. The court’s words serve as a dire warning and a call for reform to prevent further abuse of Section 498A.
The tragic suicides of Bengaluru techie Atul Subhash and Delhi café co-founder Puneet Khurana serve as stark reminders of the human cost of this misuse. Atul Subhash, a 34-year-old professional, took his life after enduring relentless harassment from his estranged wife and her family. His heartbreaking video and 24-page suicide note revealed his ordeal, including allegations of systemic corruption where a judge allegedly demanded a bribe to settle his case. These revelations paint a grim picture of the intersection of personal vendettas and systemic failures that pushed him to the brink.
Similarly, Puneet Khurana’s suicide on New Year’s Eve underscores the toll such harassment can take. Puneet, co-founder of a well-known café in Delhi, had been embroiled in a contentious marital and business dispute with his wife. Audio recordings and other evidence point to persistent threats and demands, including financial extortion and the threat of implicating his parents in false cases. His tragic end, after years of emotional and mental torture, highlights the urgent need for systemic safeguards to prevent such abuses.
These cases are not isolated incidents but symptoms of a larger problem that needs to be confronted with seriousness and resolve. While the intent behind Section 498A is noble, its implementation has, in some instances, turned into a weapon for personal vendettas. The misuse of the law, coupled with the lack of adequate safeguards, has led to devastating consequences, including loss of life. This growing trend necessitates immediate action, both in the form of legislative amendments and a rethinking of how such cases are investigated and prosecuted.
Amending Section 498A to include stringent checks and balances is critical to ensuring that genuine cases of harassment are addressed without allowing the law to be exploited. A thorough preliminary investigation should be mandated before registering cases, and mediation should be encouraged as a first step in resolving disputes. Additionally, penalties for filing false complaints must be enforced to deter misuse. Law enforcement agencies need to be trained to discern between genuine cases and baseless allegations, and judicial oversight must be strengthened to prevent undue harassment.
As a society, we must recognise the gravity of this issue and advocate for reforms that protect all individuals from abuse, regardless of gender. While women’s safety and empowerment remain essential, the misuse of laws meant to protect them cannot be ignored. The tragic stories of Atul Subhash and Puneet Khurana are powerful reminders that justice must be impartial and balanced. Their untimely deaths should galvanise society, lawmakers, and the judiciary into action to ensure that such tragedies are not repeated. A fair and just legal system is not just a necessity; it is a fundamental pillar of a civilised society.
